Tampa mayoral candidates' strong support makes for tough decisions this election

Tampa mayoral candidates' strong support makes for tough decisions this election

Carl Slifer faces a conundrum.

The Tampa resident wants to vote in the upcoming mayoral election March 22″but he's still undecided as to who will receive his vote. Rose Ferlita, he says, has a strong track record of fiscal responsibility and leadership, but Bob Buckhorn appears to have a more clear-cut vision for the future of the city.

“Honestly, I don't usually have to look at the finer points in an election because I can vote for the person who will most respect the gay community,” Slifer said. “But this is a tough call.”

In interviews with Watermark, both Ferlita and Buckhorn said they support LGBT causes and that they admire outgoing Tampa Mayor Pam Iorio's work in bringing equality to the city. Iorio incorporated domestic partnership benefits, for example, when she first took office in 2003.

“I was [former mayor] Sandy Freeman's assistant for eight years when we passed the original Human Rights Ordinance,” Buckhorn recalls. “I have also stayed in the fight and plan to continue doing everything I can to move equality forward”including all of Pam's initiatives.”

For Ferlita, watching Iorio enact the Domestic Partnership policy in 2003 wasn't enough. She wanted to voice her support for it as a city council member.

“I could have kept quiet, but at the next meeting I said, “This is not something legislative. Pam put in an executive order and I wanted to say I endorse what she did.' There is no place in my record for anything I believe in that shows just because someone is gay he or she should not get the same rights. I just don't believe that.”

For those who are afraid that the candidates will use LGBTs as a wedge issues in the final days of the campaign, both say that's not in their nature.

“There is no room for wedges in fairness,” says Ferlita during an interview in her campaign headquarters. “I'm so strong about that “¦ and I believe in this. I practice what I preach and with me as mayor, there will be zero inequality.”

Buckhorn, who was a city councilman from 1995 to 2003, says he would keep Iorio's policies intact if he were elected mayor.

The county issue
City and county government are two different entities. But for many LGBTs, Tampa gained the wrong kind of attention in 2005 when former Hillsborough County Commissioner Ronda Storms led a crusade to ban LGBT Pride displays and events in the county. 

“I don't trust the county,” says Greg Aerostan, who lives in north Tampa. “Ever since Ronda Storms went crazy, I avoid the county parks and any county events. I can't forgive them.”

Aerostan says that he and his partner both plan to vote for Ferlita in the upcoming election because of her vocal support for LGBT rights in the past. Buckhorn, they say, doesn't have the track record.

“I don't know that much about his social stances,” Aerostan says. “I've never seen him at any LGBT events, but Rose is always around showing her support. I was excited when she won the March 1 election.”

Ferlita finished just two percentage points ahead of Buckhorn in that election. The two beat Ed Turanchik, Thomas Scott and former mayor Dick Greco to advance to the runoff.

The county's Gay Pride ban, which is still in effect, prevents shows of  LGBT pride”ranging from parades to library book displays”from happening on county property. Fortunately, events have been able to move forward within Tampa's city limits.

But in the age of cost-cutting economics, some politicos have suggested Tampa merge its Parks and Recreation Department with that of Hillsborough County”meaning all park areas would be under the ban.
Neither candidate foresees that merge in their respective futures as mayor.

“Let me be clear: I am no Ronda Storms,” Rose Ferlita says. “I never thought that was a good policy. I can see the benefits of the merge as far as equipment sharing, etc. But I'd never allow that to go forward.

“The City of Tampa under my watch would never abide by what is in Hillsborough. I think that is a blatant discrimination of rights for the gay community.”

Buckhorn says that the move by Hillsborough County to ban gay pride was political and was the “lowest common denominator” of politics.

“We as a city want to celebrate our diversity,” Buckhorn says. “It's a strength for us and it gives us a competitive advantage.”

The GaYbor connection
Walking through Ybor City, it's clear that the community has a divided opinion as to who should be Tampa's next Mayor. Signs dotting the popular historic area showcase Ferlita's green and black signs and Buckhorn's signs with black lettering on an orange background.

“It”s pretty evenly split,” says Carla Vaughan, who works at the Ritz Ybor. “I think people here are drawn to both candidates.”

The renaissance of Ybor City, thanks to the formation in 2008 of the GaYbor Coalition, has brought praise from Tampa's leadership. Iorio was consistently present at openings of new businesses and the coalition honored her at a special luncheon last year.

According to one-time city council candidate Carrie West, who opened MC Film Festival along with his partner of 33 years. Mark Bias in the now-popular area, more than 20 new businesses have opened in the district since the organization formed.

Only a few empty storefronts remain.

Buckhorn is thrilled with the progress made in the area and praises West and Bias for their leadership and entrepreneurship.

“I've been impressed with how organized they are and what they have brought in as capital,” Buckhorn says. “They've asked so little from the government and this was a move entirely self-initiated by a group of entrepreneurs.”

The improvements to the area are also impressive to Ferlita, who was raised in Ybor City.

“It's fantastic and I'm a supporter,” Ferlita says. “I have a building there where someone is going to open a business. When she decided to open it, she and I went to the GaYbor meeting and she became a member. GaYbor has revitalized Ybor City.”

As of press time, the coalition had not officially endorsed a candidate, and members riding on the GaYbor St. Patrick's Day float on March 12 donned buttons and stickers for both candidates.

A sign hanging in the storefront of West and Bias' popular store, however, belongs to Buckhorn.

“I think that speaks volumes,” Buckhorn says about his sign. “I'm so proud of these guys and that organization for what they've accomplished. Ultimately, it's about economic development.”

Ferlita believes she has support from many GaYbor members as well, but her Republican affiliation in previous campaigns (Tampa City Council and Hillsborough County Commission) makes some LGBT business owners uneasy. Any party affiliation does not define her social stances, she says.

“I understand through hearsay that some of the GaYbor members are going to support my opposition,” Ferlita says. “I hear the reasoning is they felt that since Rose Ferlita is a Republican that the gay community will not be respected or not be taken care of. That's hurtful, given what I've shown and what I do and what I believe in.”

Ferlita added that right-wing Republicans are not “crazy about Rose Ferlita” because of her stance on social issues, but she is proud of her liberal social stances.

“If Rose Ferlita loses this race, the gay community also loses,” says Ferlita, who describes herself as fiscally conservative but socially liberal. “If I win, the gay community wins.”

The mayoral race is non-partisan.

Doing homework

So the problem remains”which candidate should the LGBT community support? Both candidates say they'd be visible at LGBT events and that equality is at the forefront of their campaigns.

“It's frustrating, but in a good way,” Slifer laughs. “I actually feel like a mainstream voter this election. For once I have to look at the issues rather than simply voting for the person who isn't an asshole.”

Ferlita encourages LGBTs to research her policies and to “do their homework.”

“I've done my homework and I think the gay community needs to do its homework  about me. You will find that Ferlita is the real deal and if they vote for me, they won't be sorry.”

Buckhorn says he would invite the LGBT community to voice their concerns to his mayor's office.

“I want [the LGBT community's] passion and energy,” he says. “I want them to feel they have a seat at the table and that they are invested in not just me, but the vision, hopes and aspirations of the entire community. The LGBT community is an integral part of who we are as a city.”

While Slifer may be conflicted, the candidates say they are very different when it comes to what they have planned for the city of Tampa.

“It's in what others are saying,” Buckhorn says. “Everyone who looks at those plans we rolled out four or five months ago”and the plans she rolled out after people voted”seem to favor my plan. I think the test is this: is my plan credible? Yes, it's head and shoulders above [Ferlita's]. It's detailed enough that people can hold me accountable.”

Ferlita says her business experience and familiarity with the city makes her the better choice.

“Pam has left us in great shape financially, but you have to build on that,” Ferlita says. “In these times, the mayor should be focused on the needs, not the wants, of the citizens. But I want it to be a fun time and not all doom and gloom. You take care of business first and engage the arts. Amenities downtown are important and the diversity is our fiber.”

Slifer admits he has a lot of reading to do.

“I'm on both candidates' websites all the time to read what they're all about,” he says. “Fortunately, I think whoever is elected will be an asset to the LGBT community and for the first time in my life, I'm not afraid to watch the election results.”

More in Tampa Bay

See More