One couple has been married for almost 34 years, another for 23. The other one is in their second year of marriage after two previous years of living together. Taken together, they exemplify interesting trends about LGBT household finances. Same-sex couples are bucking the dated romantic idea of a single, combined account.
“Comingling your accounts is an old, straight notion from the 1940s,” says David Schuler, who met his partner Dennis Pierce in a bar in Omaha in 1976.
Early on, Schuler simply had to defy that notion: “In our first house, we had a roommate. It was not a ménage a trios!” Schuler quickly corrects with a laugh. “So, I actually had to keep a ledger, dividing the rent, groceries and such in thirds.”
That pattern set up a “house account” that survived past the roommate and provided a nascent financial structure for their 34-year marriage.
“It's just easier that he has his account, I keep mine. Over time, we've divided things out more for tax benefits, like Dennis pays the mortgage, because it's more advantageous for him to take the tax write-off. Plus, I'm a domestic goddess, so I buy the groceries and household items,” Schuler jokes.
A separate house bank account is a possible solution: “We kick into it every week,” says Orlando resident Steve Brooks, who met his partner Paul Driver at the old community center in 1988. “It keeps us from having to talk about who paid the garbage this month, who paid the electrical. We could just write a check from the house account.”
Hashing out the finances may seem terribly unromantic, but all three couples say it's vital to starting a relationship on strong footing.
“Setting up a system early saves you from heartache later,” Brooks says. “That being said, there are some things that Paul picks up, just because he's more interested in us having.”
He jokes that tech-savvy Driver buys the electronics and “anything that requires intelligence,” while hairdresser Brooks purchases the “pretty stuff” like paint and decorations.
“I think it works better having separate accounts, because then we're not going into each other's account and asking, “Why did you spend money on this or that?'” says Tampa resident Jessie Steffens who has known her high-school sweetheart Barbara Griffin for eleven years. Two years ago they were married.
“We can buy each other stuff and get away with it,” Steffens adds good-naturedly. “You pay the bills first; whatever's left over is fun money.”
All three couples also suggest meeting with an attorney to hash out the long-term paperwork, especially in a world where gay marriage isn't yet legal. Schuler and Pierce have a will, living will, and a healthcare surrogate. The Brooks-Drivers have wills, power of attorney, and medal surrogacy. They also have a family trust, and everything they own lists both as trustees.
Brooks mentioned that, legally in America, if one partner dies, family can still come out of the woodwork and claim property both have shared for decades.
“Paul's family has only recently started to come around. I only got invited to dinner with them this last year,” Brooks says after 23-years in the relationship.
“We have a living will, and I have her as a beneficiary on my life insurance,” Steffens says. “We are actually trying to have a child, hopefully this year, so we have a lot of other agreements we need to draw up.”
Though Steffens and Griffin have great credit, it isn't all smooth sailing They also have credit card and student loan debts, and they're “kind of upside-down” on their mortgage, which has both their names on.
“It didn't give us a tax break, because the government doesn't recognize our marriage,” Steffens says. “In the long run, it would've been better to have only one name on the house, and then the other could've done the paperwork on a new place.”
It wasn't always easy for the long-term couples, either.
In 1989, Schuler lost his job and moved down to Orlando, away from Pierce, who kept his position and income in Omaha waiting for a local opportunity to transfer. “It took a year and a half to do that,” Schuler says. “That was hard.”
Almost a decade ago, the Brooks-Drivers had to figure out their finances after a break-in cleared out most of their valuables and damaged their property.
“That was fun,” Brooks quips sarcastically.
Each couple has tips they're willing to offer.
“Maintain your separate accounts,” advises Schuler. “So if I want to buy a new shirt or shoes, as long as we meet our financial obligations to our relationship and home, the rest is my money.”
“Ignoring you money problems won't make them go away,” adds Brooks. “You've got to talk it out.”