Crossing the Aisle: Republican leaders are slowly backing gay marriage

Crossing the Aisle: Republican leaders are slowly backing gay marriage

On Feb. 23, the Obama administration made a historical announcement that it would no longer defend the constitutionality of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), a federal law that bans the recognition of same-sex marriage.

Unlike previous decisions surrounding gay marriage support, Republicans were cautiously muted when it came to objections about the president's decision to no longer fight for DOMA. 

That's surprising to some, but not to others, who see a shift in the Republican ranks when it comes to how same-sex marriage is viewed.

“The Supreme Court has previously ruled that the right to marry is a fundamental constitutional right,” Fox News analyst and conservative blogger Margaret Hoover wrote in a recent post. “When an unpopular minority is denied the right to marry, it is indeed the role of the courts to protect the rights of that minority, especially when a majority would deny them.” 
RepublicanSupport4GaysShe goes onto say that conservatives have a “flawed history with civil rights.” 

“The potential consequence that conservatives land on the wrong side of civil rights history again is the alienation of an entire generation of voters,” she says. “There are multiple reasons for conservatives to think carefully before digging in their heels against gay marriage.”

Of course, not all Republicans or Conservatives agree with Hoover. Some are already seeing the subject of gay marriage fueling the 2012 elections. According to Family Research Council leader Tony Perkins, Obama has essentially laid down the gauntlet.

“The president was kind of tossing this cultural grenade into the Republican camp,” he Told the Washington Post when talking about the president's DOMA decision. “If they ignore this, it becomes an issue that will lead to some very troubling outcomes for Republicans.” 

Jon Davidson, legal director of the gay-rights group Lambda Legal, predicted the DOMA announcement would energize opponents of gay marriage, but he questioned whether that would have much impact on the 2012 presidential race. 

“I think they will try to turn this into a major election issue,” he said. “But the people who feel strongly that same-sex couples should not be allowed to marry were not going to vote for President Obama anyway.” 

So in the wake of the DOMA announcement, the response from the conservative, Republican camp has been surprisingly quiet. Could Republicans finally be giving into the fight against marriage equality?

“The wedge has lost its edge,” George W. Bush Republican strategist Mark McKinnon told the New York Times shortly after the administration's announcement. McKinnon worked for President Bush during his 2004 campaign when gay marriage ballot measures in 12 states helped turn out conservative voters.

In November 2010, a CNN/Pew Research poll of registered republicans revealed that 41 percent of Republicans favored marriage equality for same-sex couples. Taking a more highlighted approach, many stars of the Republican Party and their younger relatives have voiced their support for marriage equality, leading many to believe that it is an inevitability.

Barbara Bush, daughter of former President George W. Bush, voiced her support for gay marriage in HRC's online PSA video to bring marriage equality to New York. 

“I'm Barbara Bush and I'm a New Yorker for marriage equality,” she says in the video. “New York is about fairness and equality and everyone should have the right to marry the person that they love. Join us.” 

The video, part of a series featuring high-profile New Yorkers, comes as rights advocates make a renewed push to legalize same-sex marriage in the Empire State, after the legislature blocked such a step in December 2009.

Barbara's mother, Laura Bush, is also a supporter of same-sex marriage.

“When couples are committed to each other and love each other, they ought to have the same sort of rights that everyone has,” Laura Bush told former CNN show host Larry King. She said she and her husband do not agree on the issue.

It's not only the Bush family that is breaking the ranks from the former president. Former Vice President Dick Cheney said in 2009 that he does not “have any problems” with gays and lesbians getting married but said legalization should remain a state issue. 

“I think “¦ freedom means freedom for everyone,” said Cheney, who's daughter Mary is a lesbian and in a committed relationship with a woman. “I think people ought to be free to enter into any kind of union they wish, any kind of arrangement they wish.”

It certainly appears that the younger generation of Republicans are leading the fight for the acceptance of marriage equality in their party”and often they influence their parents. Recently, Cindy McCain, wife of Arizona Senator John McCain, voiced her support for gay marriage”nearly a year after her daughter, Meghan, did the same.

While John McCain was battling against the repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Cindy and Meghan posed for photos in the NOH8 campaign. 

Meghan voiced her support for same-gender marriage in 2009, saying, “I think more Republicans need to start taking a stand for civil rights in this country and set the example that is not a partisan issue.”

Meanwhile the senator said he respects the views of his wife and family, but that he “believes the sanctity of marriage is only defined as between one man and one woman.”

Other Republicans are stepping forward to support marriage equality as well”including former Solicitor General Ted Olson and former Republican National Committee Chairman Ken Mehlman.

There are still plenty of Republicans opposed to same-sex marriage, and Laura Bush knows that it will take a lot to change Republican minds.

“I understand totally what George (W. Bush) thinks and what other people think about marriage being between a man and a woman,” she says. “And it's a real … reversal really for [them] to accept gay marriage.”

More in News

See More